Monday, November 16, 2026

Mathologer’s Youtube Channel Resource Review

Mathologer is a mathematical educational YouTube channel created in 2015 and has over one hundred math-related videos. Mathologer’s content creator is Burkard Polster, a German mathematician and a professor of mathematics at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia.

His videos use geometries and visuals to help transfer the concepts. It is entertainment without sacrificing mathematical rigour.

The first Mathologer’s video I watched was a video confronting Numberphile’s video about 1+2+3+4+… = -1/12. And about 5 years ago I saw a Mathologer video about the 3-4-7 star phenomenon that is related to Spirographs that inspired me to write a small web app to make some star animations.

Overall my opinion is that Mathologer is a good mathematical educator, with topics ranging from high school math to much more advanced math and numerical methods topics, and presented in a way that make the concepts accessible, and even if the concept is complex, it is somewhat easy to follow.

Friday, October 23, 2026

Group Micro Teaching

 Lesson Plan: The Trigonometric Identities

Course: Pre-Calculus 12 | Time: 15 minutes | Co-Teachers: Medha, Malik, Francisco, Mahnaz

Learning Objectives:
By the end of the lesson, students will be able to:
1. Identify Illegal moves in algebraic proofs (like cross-multiplying, possible zeroes).

2. Use algebraic strategies (like common denominators, conjugates) to prove an identity.

3. Construct a proof.

Space and Material:
Space: classroom, group seating

Material: Handouts, Mini whiteboards, Whiteboard Markers.



Below is our lesson plan:

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Reflection on Microteaching: Phonetics

Reflection

I think timing is a common issue. It's hard to know how long something will take if you've never done it. You (or in this specific case I) may have practiced it solo, and pretending there were students there, but it's not the same thing. When you practice teaching to an empty class, no one looks at you funny, because there is no one there. Unless someone is watching from outside, then they will probably look at you funny exactly because you are teaching to no one... But estimating time well enough will probably come with practice and repetition and teaching the same thing a couple times, and then you know roughly how long the activities take.

You just need a single student to have this "what do you mean?" look, and then all the planning (and half of the confidence) goes down the drain. The fix will most likely come with practice, where the looks don't give you the same fright when you are still unsure of your abilities.

I know I chose a small topic that most people are oblivious to, which is surprising because everyone talks. Most people just don't know how or why. And that was exactly the plan! To make it a bit more intentional!

I guess the main takeaway is that I need practice? Teaching, like with most things in life, as they say, "practice makes perfect". Or at least practice makes less terrible, I hope...

A Surprise

I had planned the idea of the progression, the place of articulation, and the voiced [z], but what I didn't expect was when I asked the students to fill in the column of place of articulation, one student put the vocal fold as the place of articulation for the [z]. Which is not exactly right, but it is absolutely amazing that they found out that the [z] uses the vocal fold. It is voiced! I used it as a great hook to move to the activity of detecting if a consonant is voiceless or voiced.

The Peer-Assessments

Everyone noticed the lack of time for the last activity, and this was a common trend in the comments. My peers finished the activity with a positive impression, so I'm not sure if they are being too nice to me or if I'm just being too mean to myself... Another common piece of comment was that they liked that they could explore together and that it was a safe space to try and fail. There was one comment saying they wanted more of the vocabulary that I intentionally removed. "Lateral fricative", in this example the "voiceless" kind, was what we explored last. I didn't think adding those terms would be of any benefit, but guess I was wrong! Next time (if there's ever a next time) I'll add them, but in a way that doesn't make it too scary. Crazy complex words no one ever saw before can be intimidating...

In the ratings department we had:

  1. Sequencing & Structure was between 2 and 3
  2. Clarity & Content also between 2 and 3, but leaning more towards 3
  3. Timing & Pacing was bad (trust me, no need to look at the data)
  4. Planning & Knowledge received more than 2s all around, which is great for me!
  5. Learner Engagement received 3s all around, which is great for... them?
  6. Confidence & Presence they all got it wrong! They put 3... As if I had any confidence at all... Maybe I was just able to fake it?

Here are the slips:

Kia
a) 3  ·  b) 2.5  ·  c) 2  ·  d) 2.5  ·  e) 3  ·  f) 3
Very clear + engaging delivery, with great participation element! I also really appreciate the incorporation of some other cultures/languages. The pacing could maybe have been switched up & have a bit more structured time for that final discussion, but overall great work!



Kieran
a) 2  ·   b) 3  ·   c) 2  ·   d) 3  ·   e) 3  ·   f) 3
This was great! I learned a lot. My only bit of feedback would be to have some more vocabulary provided on worksheet, i.e. lateral fricative. The best part was how we were all exploring it together.



Leo
a) 2.5  ·   b) 2.5  ·   c) 2  ·   d) 3  ·   e) 3  ·   f) 3
Very knowledgeable wish there was more time. Students engagement at the activity maybe?



Tara Petrie
a) 2.5  ·   b) 3  ·   c) 3  ·   d) 3  ·   e) 3  ·   f) 3
Despite not having much time to do the last exercise, I like how the activity was paced to allow us each to try everything on the list + consider each sound — that didn't feel rushed! And it was a fun + engaging activity. You made me feel like I could try + fail + that was okay. Great diagram too!

Self-Assessment

Or, how I like to call it, the Answer Key:

Francisco (self-assessment)
a) 2  ·   b) 2  ·   c) 1  ·   d) 3  ·   e) 3  ·   f) 2
Not enough time for the group activity. Was not ready with the handout at the start of the lecture.


One small piece of detail is that when my timer started counting, I was still finishing the last activity's peer assessment, and I wasn't ready with the handouts. That destabilized a bit, I have to admit. Wouldn't have made enough time for the last activity regardless. The lack of time was just bad planning overall.

Conclusion

I think everyone has a more positive view of the activity than me because they came in not knowing what to expect. I had my plan, which I failed miserably to accomplish, so when I look at the theoretical target, I see 100%. I usually expect at least 110% from me, which doesn't really help. And when I tried to apply it in practice, I got to a 63% at most. And that is definitely not good. When my peers see the same 63, they don't see it out of 100. It was 63 out of basically nothing, which seems really good. So maybe they only thought it was good because they didn't know how much gooder it could be. Or maybe it wasn't as terrible as I think it was. Maybe it was something in between. We'll never know.

Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Microteaching: Phonetics - Making Speech Intentional

Big Idea

Speaking is something we do mostly subconsciously. If we notice what the tongue, lips, air, and vocal folds are doing, we can start to control them on purpose. That awareness also helps when learning a new language that has a sound we're not familiar with.

Learning Objective

Students can describe a speech sound with three questions, and use those questions to guide how they produce a sound:

  1. Where does the mouth/tongue close, touch, or narrow?
  2. What is the air doing? Stopped, hissing, slipping around the sides, or through the nose?
  3. Is the voice on or off?

Lesson Sequence

The handout has no instructions; the teacher leads it one column at a time. Filling the "Where" column first shows that [t], [d], [s], [z], and [l] share the same place of articulation, which raises the question the other two columns answer.

Time Step What happens
0:00–1:00 Hook Teacher raises awareness about the movement happening in the mouth as we speak. Students are instructed to engage with their vocal apparatus.
1:00–2:30 Where column Teacher guides the students to fill the "Where" column of the handout with the places of articulation of the listed sounds.
2:30–4:00 Air column Teacher compares [t] sound with [s] sound. Guides students to hold a [t] and just create a tiny passage of air from the tip of the tongue by lowering it slightly, creating the [s] sound. Students continue for the other sounds.
4:00–5:30 Voice column Teacher compares [s] sound with [z] sound. Students place a hand on the throat to feel the vocal folds vibrate. Teacher introduces the terms voiced and voiceless. Students use this to explain the difference between [t] and [d], and continue for the other sounds.
5:30–7:00 Challenge: [ɬ] (optional) Teacher guides students from [l] towards [t]: widening the tongue to almost full closure, leaving a small gap at the sides, with the voice off, creating the [ɬ] sound. Teacher mentions that this sound occurs in many Indigenous languages of the Pacific Northwest coast, including in BC.
7:00–9:15 Partner In pairs, each student chooses a sound their partner may not know (any sound, or one from another language) and guides their partner to produce it using the three questions rather than imitation. Partners note the sound at the bottom of the handout.
9:15–10:00 Close Teacher recaps: speech is mostly subconscious, but it can be examined and controlled on purpose using the three questions.

If time runs short, skip [ɬ]. The partner step needs at least two minutes.

Differentiation and Inclusion

  • Each feature can be noticed in several ways: by ear, by touch (tongue, throat), and on the diagram.
  • The diagram uses plain words, with technical terms in small print for reference. Plain descriptions are accepted.
  • Any sound can be used in the partner step; students may bring sounds from other languages.

Materials

Assessment

Formative; nothing is collected. Teacher listens to students' answers and checks the handout while leading each column. In the partner step, success is using the three questions to explain or adjust a sound, not producing it perfectly. The handout stays with the students as a reference.

Thoughts on Malihe's Activity

For what I understand, Malihe's activity was to show the struggle of international students and parents with things like language, culture, school dynamics, and all the stress involved with moving.

What caught me by surprise a little bit were the similarities between what Malihe described about school in Iran and my experience in Brazil. I'll start by saying that my high school experience in Brazil was quite some time ago and that things may be different today.

I'll start by pointing out the differences. Language, of course, is different. Moving from Iran to Canada or from Brazil to Canada both have language barriers, but I'd argue the language difference in the activity is significantly greater than what I experienced. Portuguese and English both use basically the same Latin alphabet, the same numerals, and the same reading direction, while Farsi uses a modified Arabic alphabet, different numerals, and different reading directions (except for numbers?). Malihe mentioned the difficult access to the internet in Iran, and while mobile data was not exactly a thing while I was in high school, home internet connections were available, even if not great.

There were other small things that were somewhat similar, but maybe not to the same intensity, for example, religion. While in Iran Quran studies are apparently an important subject in high school, in Brazil religious studies are usually not part of the curriculum. I went to a private Catholic school run by nuns, where religion was part of the school curriculum up to grade 11.

Part of Malihe's activities were to find extracurricular activities in Tehran, like guitar lessons and volleyball clubs, and although it was hard (and the language barrier didn't help), it didn't seem impossible. Part of the activity was to realize that those activities are not available in the schools and that there is no such thing as a community centre. Those activities are harder to find there compared to here, and prices and schedules are only available upon contact by email or phone. In my school music was only available until 5th grade or so, arts only up to 7th or 8th grade (I don't remember), and physical education was a thing all throughout school. In Brazil community centres are also not common (or at least they weren't when and where I'm from). If the kid wants to participate in any of those extracurricular activities, parents must have the financial means, local knowledge, and usually access to private clubs.

But many things that may have seemed alien to Canadian high schoolers were actually not surprising at all to me. The fixed-schedule non-elective stream-based high school was pretty similar to my experience. We had no options on the classes we took. The whole year schedule was determined by the school for all the students, and it was the same for every student of a grade until grade 10. At the end of grade 10, we chose between three specialized streams: exact sciences (math, physics, and inorganic chemistry), biological and health sciences (biology, organic chemistry, and earth sciences), and humanities and social sciences (history, sociology, political science, and literature).

Another thing that Malihe apparently mentioned to shock the Canadian students was that schools in Iran are walled. They feature high walls all around, a single entrance/exit for students that is open only during the start and end of the school day, and a smaller entrance for staff, parents, and visitors—usually with security. I don't know the specific reason for that in Iran, but in Brazil, we have the exact same thing to keep students safe inside (and sometimes our walls even have broken glass at the top to prevent anyone from climbing them). An unrelated cultural shock for me when I arrived in Canada was the fact that anyone could just... walk into a bank. In Brazil, banks have rotating doors with metal detectors and security guards inside elevated bulletproof cabins carrying shotguns. Compared to that, walled schools don't seem that hardcore, honestly...

Malihe mentioned standardized tests, high academic demand, and a strict subject focus in Iran, contrasting it with Canada's more holistic, community-oriented mindset that prioritizes deep understanding over raw computational efficiency (specifically in mathematics). In Brazil, we also had a national standardized test for university admission—a high-stakes, future-defining exam.

I think this activity worked beautifully to show how easily someone can feel lost upon arriving in Canada due to these systemic differences. A student who has spent their entire life having their schedules completely predetermined must suddenly decide what they are going to learn in a new school, all while navigating language barriers and intense culture shock. It can easily become overwhelming. Parents face a similar wave of stress navigating a new country, new jobs, a new language, a new culture, and even a new climate! Furthermore, the extracurricular activities available at local community centres are only truly accessible if families know they exist. Local community knowledge and language proficiency can easily become systemic barriers to these exact opportunities.

My own background, combined with a fundamental understanding that school dynamics vary globally, will allow me to deeply empathize with international students. Ultimately, I hope this perspective enables me to make their transition and adaptation process significantly less stressful.

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Reflection on the Art Project

I’ll start by saying that a lot of things we do in life (and school is no different), we do because we have to. Because someone said so. Because that’s they are paying you for. Because that’s what will decide if you pass or fail. Because that’s what is expected of you. And obviously this project was no different, as this is, after all, an assignment.

When you do something because you really like, because you really enjoy, and because you really want to, everything is different. I’ll admit this project started as an assignment, as an obligation. I possibly wouldn’t have done it if I wasn’t “forced” to. But from the moment I saw Nadal’s dodecahedron it resonated with me. And then this became more than a mere assignment for grades. This became a project. And I poured a lot of my passion into it. Since the project was presented one week ago, the web app I created or it has received more than a dozen revisions. That’s no longer for marks. That’s no longer an obligation. That is passion! And that project is surely something I’ll keep working on and improving for a long time.

The dodecahedron, for me, is more than a mere polyhedron, or just a shape, an object. I am an avid tabletop game player, from fun party games, to board games that span over twelve hours in one sitting, to role playing games that go for years. So when I see the dodecahedron I see what I call a D12, that is a die with 12 faces. Many are familiar with the D6, the die with 6 faces, that is present in a lot of board games and dice games, like Yahtzee! But the dice family has many more members: the D12 that Nadal chose, the D20 that my group chose, and there are D10, D8, D4, and some other less known members. Another fun member is the D%, or D100, the percentile dice. While there are some options of polyhedron with 100 faces, many players use two D10: one for the units, and one for the tens place. And that’s why my web application project can do what Nadal did with the dodecahedron and what my group did with the icosahedron to all those members. Because I like board games. And I like math. And I like interactive applications. So there we have i.

Two of the things that were notorious for me during this project (other than the 3D printing, and the prototyping, and the trials and errors, and the flimsiness of paper) were how interlocked the caps were and how problematic the D10 was.

Nadal’s art project added the symbolism of Yin Yang, and how the two opposites are connected and interlocked. I just didn’t expect them to be that interlocked. After careful analysis (and some trial and error) I realized that the caps for the D4 and D6 could be rigid and still connect and complete each other, but as the number of faces increases they start becoming too interlocked, to the point that I couldn’t have rigid caps. They needed to be somewhat malleable in order to connect: too rigid of a cap and it wouldn’t be able to “open its arms” to embrace the other cap. That made me try faces with hinge connections for the caps, and then magnets to keep things closed. There were several designs, and many prototypes, but I think I finally ended up on something that I liked. And it worked reasonably well!

The D10 was a problem for mostly everything. From the shape, to the design, to the strips, to the Schlegel diagram. Everything was wrong with the D10. And there is a good reason for that, one that I don’t think I’ve appreciated that much in all my years as a dice roller: the D10 is not a Platonic Solid! I mean, I knew that, and I knew that the D10’s faces were not a regular polygon, but they worked as anything else. But the D10 is the only non Platonic Solid of all those most famous dice. The five Platonic Solids are the Tetrahedron (D4), the Hexahedron (the cube, also known as the D6), the Octahedron (D8), the Dodecahedron (D12), and the Icosahedron (D20). And they are nice, and they are perfect, and things work really nice on them. The D10, on the other hand, is not. It is a Pentagonal Trapezohedron! It’s a nice polyhedron, where all the faces are the same kite shape. And it’s possibly the most fair 10-sided die. There are many other options, but as there is no Platonic Solid with 10 faces, it had to be improvised. And even though it is beautifully engineered, it’s brings a lot of challenges for the “general case” software. Many things assumed regular faces, regular distribution, and regular a lot of things. The D10 has none of those. Yes, their faces are the same kite shape, but instead of faces nicely distributed around a sphere, the Pentagonal Trapezohedron has 5 faces on one hemisphere and 5 on the other, with just that symmetry. It feels like a workaround. It is in the same group of dice, but it is not as gracious as the others. It is the best it could be, but I wonder how better life would be if there was a Platonic Solid with 10 faces. Or maybe we just need to forget the base 10 and go with something better that would make the D10 unnecessary. Like for example, no one is bothered if a D14 is not a Platonic Solid. No one uses them. No one cares…

Good thing the D10 is the only non-Platonic Solid on the project, it would be messy if I had to create special-cases for D14s and D3s and the such.

Monday, September 28, 2026

From Nadal’s Dodecahedron to Our Icosahedron

 Group Members: Francisco, Jasmeet and Parminder


Original Artwork: Desconstrucció d'un dodecàedre by Josep Rey Nadal


Remaking the Original Artwork & The Artist's Vision

To truly understand the intersection of mathematics and sculpture, our first step was to reverse-engineer Josep Rey Nadal’s original work, Desconstrucció d'un dodecàedre.

Nadal describes his work as an exploration of symmetry, spatial bisection, and philosophical balance. By cutting the regular dodecahedron along a continuous path, the solid unzips into two identical, complementary halves that fit together as a three-dimensional manifestation of the Yin and Yang. It visually demonstrates how two opposing, interlocking parts contain the complete whole.




Our Remake: We remade the original dodecahedron using durable cardstock. Replicating the form out of paper required precise measurements and clean folds. Our main snag was managing the structural stability of the paper joints while executing the bisecting cuts. Working through this hands-on assembly revealed how a continuous path along a 3D solid acts as a hidden seam, transforming a flat net into a dynamic, separable 3D network.


Our Artistic and Mathematical Extension: We wanted to build upon Nadal’s concept of bisection while introducing two major changes: a geometric shift and a deliberate material swap. We moved from a dodecahedron (12 pentagonal faces, 20 vertices) to an icosahedron (20 triangular faces, 12 vertices), exploring mathematical duality and symmetry on a different polyhedron. We designed our own 3D replica of the icosahedron (https://faamorim.github.io/hamiltonian-polyhedron/), which provided the digital foundation for our model. 

Nadal’s original piece is crafted from warm, organic wood. For our extension, we transitioned to modern 3D-printed plastic. While wood offers an earthy, traditional feel, 3D printing allowed us to achieve absolute geometric precision and clean, sharp edges. Nadal’s wooden pentagons felt organic and fluid, our 3D-printed triangles introduced sharp energy and structural tension.


Our Interactive Class Activity: To bring our peers into the mathematical and artistic process during our presentation, we wanted an activity that is tactile, low-stakes, and visual. We prepared flat 2D net cutouts of the icosahedron for our classmates so they can experience the puzzle in their own hands. During our upcoming presentation, we will also hand out templates and challenge our classmates to map out a continuous line connecting every single vertex exactly once without lifting their pens or crossing their own paths.


Once they map their paths on paper, we will reveal our 3D-printed icosahedron to demonstrate how their 2D drawings directly translate into the "secret cuts" used to bisect the 3D solid, bridging flat geometry and spatial form.


BC Curriculum Math Connection:

This project serves as a powerful, hands-on entry point for secondary mathematics, aligning closely with the British Columbia Mathematics Curriculum in the following ways:

  • Spatial Reasoning & 3D Geometry (Grades 8-10): Students often struggle to visualize how 2D nets fold into 3D objects (and vice versa). This project allows learners to physically deconstruct 3D solids, building spatial awareness and deepening their understanding of vertices, edges, faces, and Euler's characteristic.

Curricular Competencies: It directly supports competencies such as reasoning and analyzing (exploring spatial patterns), understanding and solving (tackling topological puzzles through trial and error), and communicating and representing (connecting mathematical concepts to artistic expression). By rooting abstract geometry in tactile art, it fosters a low-stress environment that encourages inquiry and reduces math anxiety.

Conservatives, Progressives, and the in-between.

While I was reading the post, almost every paragraph made me relate to the progressives and solidify my stance towards them. I do understand that not everything the opposition stands for is absurd and outdated, but I just couldn’t bear them. And my first moment that I had to take a quick brain brake was when the author mentioned that this dichotomous view of the approaches is not necessarily constructive. It is true, and the ideas do have to be discussed more in a sense of “what are the consequences of our actions” than a “I’m right and you are wrong”. There is value and use on both the progressive view and (admitting almost against my will) the conservative view. I kept reading and, although I reluctantly accepted that the conservatives weren’t that terrible, I had a hard time accepting any of their views.

Then when I got to the table again to reread it and it all made sense. It wasn’t exactly the content of the table, it was more the subjective message being passed. Just the descriptors of the conservatives makes me disagree with them. For example, the use of descriptor like “obedience” could have almost the same meaning if we used “discipline”, but it’s way harder for someone to resonate with “obedience” than it is with “discipline”. There is even a more flourished way to say basically the same thing: “adherence to established mathematical conventions”. On the other side we have descriptors like “exploratory”, which could be written in a way less flattering way as “students are expected to construct methods that may be inefficient or erroneous”. That just showed me the power of communication.

Monday, September 21, 2026

Eisner’s Curriculum

I was reading Eisner’s article, and right at the beginning where he was explaining that curriculum is what we teach and that we teach compliance, I realized that this would be a point that would have made me stop and think, but that idea of teaching compliance had already been expressed many times in just two weeks of BEd that I didn’t even skip a beat. But then the article got to the competitiveness, and mentioned physical activities and games, and yeah, that’s some competitiveness, and I think I understand some of the negative impacts, but then Eisner went deeper into the classroom dynamics, and normal distribution of grades, and university admissions, and honours, and all that, and that made me stop. Coming from a country with a different school culture, that was almost shocking. The concept wasn’t unheard for me, but I honestly thought most of it was just Hollywood exaggerations to add to the plot and highlight the good guys vs the bad guys stereotype in high school drama movies and shows. Possibly coming from a country with many standardized tests, including National Standardized Admission Exams for universities, there was none of that extreme competitiveness Eisner mentioned. That was quite something.

Another contrast, and it’s a huge section, is the entire segment on the Null Curriculum. The things you don’t teach. I’m honestly not familiar with education during Eisner’s time, but my experience growing up, your entire school schedule was set, and even university was pretty much laid out. During my time as a student, art class was just for kids. I think my last art class was grade 5 or something. There was also no philosophy, or virtually any thing Eisner mention is missing. My experience volunteering in a high school in BC in 2026 was completely different. I saw that students have many options to choose from, together with a core mandatory course list. That seems way more in line with what Eisner thought was missing.

I think the BC curriculum approaches most of those issues with an open mind, and trying to solve the issues mentioned by Eisner. Maybe the different streams of mathematics could be taken as some sort of honours classes, but I guess that is a way to make some part of math mandatory and some more complex part of math optional. From what I noticed (but I’m not exactly sure how the BC curriculum states that) students opt into those streams. The teacher may suggest to a struggling student that they could take the workplace math stream, but it is ultimately decided by the student. I guess that is possibly healthier.

Wednesday, September 16, 2026

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

During my studies I’ve come across many math teachers. Many different styles, personalities, views, approaches. Some were more in sync with me, some were less.

The Good was a high school teacher that I had. Ironically it was the teacher that gave me my worst math grades before university. I’ve always liked math, it was like a game to me. A puzzle. A challenge. So I’ve always been interested in math and was good at it. Regardless of the difficulty I may have had in other classes and subjects, I’d always get 95% or more in math. That teacher was the one to break my streak. They would challenge me more. Not only more than the previous teachers did, they would push me beyond what they would expect for the rest of the class. I asked if they could make the tests harder for me, and they were happy to. That means the tests were way harder and that reflected in my grades. But instead of getting a boring and expected 100%, I’d get a hard fought sweaty 80%. And the challenge was worth way more than the grades for me. It made math fun again. No regrets!

The Bad, on the other hand, was a thermodynamics teacher in university. Not exactly a math teacher, but it was a math heavy subject. That was a teacher that expected the students to memorize all the formulas. And as I mentioned earlier on a previous post, my memory is not that great, so that didn’t really work well for me. To be completely honest, it is possible that they didn’t really expect the students to memorize all the formulas, as they would seemingly “accept” that the students would cheat. They’d just turn a blind eye, leaving the classroom unattended for most of the time during exams. Another problem that I have is that I can’t cheat. My mind just blocks me. I tried once. I had a piece of paper inside my shoe. Just knowing it was there made me unable to focus on the test because I’d just be sweating, shaking, and drooling. I know that was just an incompatibility between me and the teacher’s style, but other than just personal capacity, I think that style silently passes the message of “this subject is so hard that regardless of how much you study it won’t be enough and you’ll have to resort to cheating”. I’ve had other physics teachers with equally hard topics that would provide the students with the formulas. That was the physics department’s policy, but was not the same for the engineering department.

That leaves the Ugly to me, I suppose. Ugly throwing shade at my future colleagues…

Tuesday, September 15, 2026

The Locker Problem

When I first read the blog post presenting the problem, I immediately concluded that each student changes the state of the lockers that have a number that is a multiple of the student’s number. That didn’t help much. I had to think of it from the lockers’ point of view.

Yeah, that’s not that hard. The locker will be changed by the students whose numbers are a factor of the locker’s number. Okay. If the lockers start open, lockers with an even number of factors would stay open and lockers with an odd number of factors would be closed. Easy. Final answer. Done.

Then I started thinking if there was a better answer for that. But how do I know which numbers have an even or odd number of factors? And I thought I’d have to brute force my way through it. No, it can’t be! That’s not how we do things. So I started thinking about factors, and as it usually goes I thought that prime numbers have only 1 and themselves as factors! That’s it. Prime numbers have an even number of factors, everything else must have an odd number, right? Then just to check I thought of 6. And it turns out that 6 has 1, 2, 3, and 6 as factors. Four factors. Four is even… Wait. Of course! Factors come in pairs. Always! The factors of a number n always come as a×b = n. But then does that mean every single number has an even number of factors and therefore every door is open? Can’t be!

I had to try and brute force the start. Starting with 1 I found that it had only itself as a factor. Wait a second there. 1 is a weird number, so maybe only 1 is closed and everything else is open? Let’s keep checking before we conclude that… Continue brute forcing: 2 has two factors, 3 has two factors, 4 has... Three? Wait! How? What about the factor pairs? 4 is 1×4 and 2×2. OOOH! One of the pairs is a number times itself! So that is a pair, but that number only shows up once in the list of factors. That is the odd factor! The factor that doesn't have a pair other than itself! The square root of the number! It has to be it! Perfect square numbers have an odd number of factors. Also, 1 is a special number in many ways, but also it is a perfect square. Of itself! Brute forced my way to 10 just to check and, as expected, locker 9 was closed!

That’s a beautiful problem. That is a problem that would make me enthusiastically tell the students “that’s why math is the most beautiful thing in the universe!” To which I know most students would just sigh, but such is life…

I built a small interactive visualisation here to help see the first 50 lockers and the first 50 students (we don't need more students because no student after the 50th would touch the first 50 lockers).


Interactive Visualisation


Monday, September 14, 2026

Instrumentality, relationality, and terrible memory.

I've always had a problem with pure instrumental understanding. I imagine part of that is because I have terrible memory, but also because I always wanted to know why. I was curious and loved the feeling of finding things out. I understand some people just want to know the easiest way to solve something, a "just give me the formula" kind of approach. Shortcuts, mnemonics, and memorizing formulas can all help with efficiency, but for me that never really stuck. Having a really bad memory could make me remember the formulas wrong. Memorizing the whole formula and mistaking a plus with a minus sign could sound like a small mistake, but that could also be as big as mistaking the gravity going down with it going up. I've seen a lot of sign mistakes on memorized formulas or on calculations but never found someone who thought gravity was pushing things up. That just shows how fragile the instrumental understanding can be, with small mistakes being huge disconnects with reality. Not that focusing on relational understanding makes calculations fail proof, but at least, if you know what the big picture is, you can look at the result and say "this doesn't seem right", and double-check your work. If you just follow a procedure with no understanding of the relations between that and the world around you, the result is just a number, and a wrong number and a right number are both just numbers.

I agree with most of what was said, including the part where the author mentions the possible reasons for instrumental understanding. But I think when the author mentioned the difficulty of assessing relational understanding, the biggest mistake was trying to do that with traditional math questions. "Solve this" and "calculate this" questions will only check the execution, not necessarily the thinking. Maybe assessments should just be different. Make some math assessments be more like humanities studies, asking students things like "what would be the next step?", or "why would we do this?", or "when would we use this?" instead of just asking for final answers. Math has number problems and word problems, but those are usually just answered with numbers. Maybe math also deserves word problems with word answers.




Thursday, September 10, 2026

Hello World!

 Hello everyone.

Let’s try to have some fun and hopefully not divide by zero.