I’ll start by saying that a lot of things we do in life (and school is no different), we do because we have to. Because someone said so. Because that’s they are paying you for. Because that’s what will decide if you pass or fail. Because that’s what is expected of you. And obviously this project was no different, as this is, after all, an assignment.
When you do something because you really like, because you really enjoy, and because you really want to, everything is different. I’ll admit this project started as an assignment, as an obligation. I possibly wouldn’t have done it if I wasn’t “forced” to. But from the moment I saw Nadal’s dodecahedron it resonated with me. And then this became more than a mere assignment for grades. This became a project. And I poured a lot of my passion into it. Since the project was presented one week ago, the web app I created or it has received more than a dozen revisions. That’s no longer for marks. That’s no longer an obligation. That is passion! And that project is surely something I’ll keep working on and improving for a long time.
The dodecahedron, for me, is more than a mere polyhedron, or just a shape, an object. I am an avid tabletop game player, from fun party games, to board games that span over twelve hours in one sitting, to role playing games that go for years. So when I see the dodecahedron I see what I call a D12, that is a die with 12 faces. Many are familiar with the D6, the die with 6 faces, that is present in a lot of board games and dice games, like Yahtzee! But the dice family has many more members: the D12 that Nadal chose, the D20 that my group chose, and there are D10, D8, D4, and some other less known members. Another fun member is the D%, or D100, the percentile dice. While there are some options of polyhedron with 100 faces, many players use two D10: one for the units, and one for the tens place. And that’s why my web application project can do what Nadal did with the dodecahedron and what my group did with the icosahedron to all those members. Because I like board games. And I like math. And I like interactive applications. So there we have i.
Two of the things that were notorious for me during this project (other than the 3D printing, and the prototyping, and the trials and errors, and the flimsiness of paper) were how interlocked the caps were and how problematic the D10 was.
Nadal’s art project added the symbolism of Yin Yang, and how the two opposites are connected and interlocked. I just didn’t expect them to be that interlocked. After careful analysis (and some trial and error) I realized that the caps for the D4 and D6 could be rigid and still connect and complete each other, but as the number of faces increases they start becoming too interlocked, to the point that I couldn’t have rigid caps. They needed to be somewhat malleable in order to connect: too rigid of a cap and it wouldn’t be able to “open its arms” to embrace the other cap. That made me try faces with hinge connections for the caps, and then magnets to keep things closed. There were several designs, and many prototypes, but I think I finally ended up on something that I liked. And it worked reasonably well!
The D10 was a problem for mostly everything. From the shape, to the design, to the strips, to the Schlegel diagram. Everything was wrong with the D10. And there is a good reason for that, one that I don’t think I’ve appreciated that much in all my years as a dice roller: the D10 is not a Platonic Solid! I mean, I knew that, and I knew that the D10’s faces were not a regular polygon, but they worked as anything else. But the D10 is the only non Platonic Solid of all those most famous dice. The five Platonic Solids are the Tetrahedron (D4), the Hexahedron (the cube, also known as the D6), the Octahedron (D8), the Dodecahedron (D12), and the Icosahedron (D20). And they are nice, and they are perfect, and things work really nice on them. The D10, on the other hand, is not. It is a Pentagonal Trapezohedron! It’s a nice polyhedron, where all the faces are the same kite shape. And it’s possibly the most fair 10-sided die. There are many other options, but as there is no Platonic Solid with 10 faces, it had to be improvised. And even though it is beautifully engineered, it’s brings a lot of challenges for the “general case” software. Many things assumed regular faces, regular distribution, and regular a lot of things. The D10 has none of those. Yes, their faces are the same kite shape, but instead of faces nicely distributed around a sphere, the Pentagonal Trapezohedron has 5 faces on one hemisphere and 5 on the other, with just that symmetry. It feels like a workaround. It is in the same group of dice, but it is not as gracious as the others. It is the best it could be, but I wonder how better life would be if there was a Platonic Solid with 10 faces. Or maybe we just need to forget the base 10 and go with something better that would make the D10 unnecessary. Like for example, no one is bothered if a D14 is not a Platonic Solid. No one uses them. No one cares…
Good thing the D10 is the only non-Platonic Solid on the project, it would be messy if I had to create special-cases for D14s and D3s and the such.
No comments:
Post a Comment