Reflection
I think timing is a common issue. It's hard to know how long something will take if you've never done it. You (or in this specific case I) may have practiced it solo, and pretending there were students there, but it's not the same thing. When you practice teaching to an empty class, no one looks at you funny, because there is no one there. Unless someone is watching from outside, then they will probably look at you funny exactly because you are teaching to no one... But estimating time well enough will probably come with practice and repetition and teaching the same thing a couple times, and then you know roughly how long the activities take.
You just need a single student to have this "what do you mean?" look, and then all the planning (and half of the confidence) goes down the drain. The fix will most likely come with practice, where the looks don't give you the same fright when you are still unsure of your abilities.
I know I chose a small topic that most people are oblivious to, which is surprising because everyone talks. Most people just don't know how or why. And that was exactly the plan! To make it a bit more intentional!I guess the main takeaway is that I need practice? Teaching, like with most things in life, as they say, "practice makes perfect". Or at least practice makes less terrible, I hope...
A Surprise
I had planned the idea of the progression, the place of articulation, and the voiced [z], but what I didn't expect was when I asked the students to fill in the column of place of articulation, one student put the vocal fold as the place of articulation for the [z]. Which is not exactly right, but it is absolutely amazing that they found out that the [z] uses the vocal fold. It is voiced! I used it as a great hook to move to the activity of detecting if a consonant is voiceless or voiced.
The Peer-Assessments
Everyone noticed the lack of time for the last activity, and this was a common trend in the comments. My peers finished the activity with a positive impression, so I'm not sure if they are being too nice to me or if I'm just being too mean to myself... Another common piece of comment was that they liked that they could explore together and that it was a safe space to try and fail. There was one comment saying they wanted more of the vocabulary that I intentionally removed. "Lateral fricative", in this example the "voiceless" kind, was what we explored last. I didn't think adding those terms would be of any benefit, but guess I was wrong! Next time (if there's ever a next time) I'll add them, but in a way that doesn't make it too scary. Crazy complex words no one ever saw before can be intimidating...
In the ratings department we had:
- Sequencing & Structure was between 2 and 3
- Clarity & Content also between 2 and 3, but leaning more towards 3
- Timing & Pacing was bad (trust me, no need to look at the data)
- Planning & Knowledge received more than 2s all around, which is great for me!
- Learner Engagement received 3s all around, which is great for... them?
- Confidence & Presence they all got it wrong! They put 3... As if I had any confidence at all... Maybe I was just able to fake it?
Here are the slips:
![]() |
Leo a) 2.5 · b) 2.5 · c) 2 · d) 3 · e) 3 · f) 3 Very knowledgeable wish there was more time. Students engagement at the activity maybe? |
Self-Assessment
Or, how I like to call it, the Answer Key:
![]() |
a) 2 · b) 2 · c) 1 · d) 3 · e) 3 · f) 2 Not enough time for the group activity. Was not ready with the handout at the start of the lecture. |
One small piece of detail is that when my timer started counting, I was still finishing the last activity's peer assessment, and I wasn't ready with the handouts. That destabilized a bit, I have to admit. Wouldn't have made enough time for the last activity regardless. The lack of time was just bad planning overall.
Conclusion
I think everyone has a more positive view of the activity than me because they came in not knowing what to expect. I had my plan, which I failed miserably to accomplish, so when I look at the theoretical target, I see 100%. I usually expect at least 110% from me, which doesn't really help. And when I tried to apply it in practice, I got to a 63% at most. And that is definitely not good. When my peers see the same 63, they don't see it out of 100. It was 63 out of basically nothing, which seems really good. So maybe they only thought it was good because they didn't know how much gooder it could be. Or maybe it wasn't as terrible as I think it was. Maybe it was something in between. We'll never know.





Thanks Francisco. I'm looking for your group curricular microteaching lesson plan that ought to have been posted here yesterday evening. Please post as soon as possible!!
ReplyDelete